But their one-on-one time went so well.
So well, in fact, it ended in a kiss and a rose.
Enter Davey Lloyd - the lovable larrikin from Sam Frost's season of The Bachelorette, and the guy who stuffed things up with Florence Alexandra in Paradise in 2018.
And Alisha liked what she saw! "I'm thinking, Paddy who?"
The pair grabbed a drink and headed for a daybed to get to know each other.
"I'm like, vibing with Davey!"
We like where this flirtation is going - tell us via our Facebook page if you do too!