Advertisement
Home Entertainment Reality Tv

My Kitchen Rules fans are divided over ‘cheating’ scandal as new scoring twist revealed

Some viewers are calling it cheating, while others reckon it's all part of the competition.
MKR 2026 Tiffany, Simon and Krysten
My Kitchen Rules fans are divided over strategic scoring as a new twist threatens to make things awkward for the remaining contestants. Credit: Channel Seven.
Advertisement

My Kitchen Rules is no stranger to controversy, and this season, it’s the contestants’ strategic scoring that’s really dividing viewers.

After Tiffany and Giancarlo’s shock elimination, fans have questioned whether deliberately giving a strong team a low score is cheating or simply the name of the game.

Now, with a new twist reportedly set to air on Monday night’s episode, it seems some contestants may find themselves in an uncomfortable position.

Loading the player…
Advertisement

Why are My Kitchen Rules fans accusing contestants of cheating?

During last week’s elimination cook-off in Kitchen HQ, Simon admitted to deliberately scoring Tiffany and Giancarlo lower because he believed he and teammate Angus would have a better chance of beating Zoe and Zac later in the competition.

Despite receiving praise and higher combined scores from judges Manu Feildel and Colin Fassnidge, the couple were sent packing by just one point.

The move left viewers outraged, with many accusing Simon of cheating his way through the competition.

“It’s still cheating, and Simon was bragging about it, which just makes it worse,” one fan wrote.

Advertisement
Simon MKR 2026
Simon admits to purposefully scoring Tiffany and Giancarlo lower. Credit: Channel Seven.

Another questioned whether the competition was still rewarding the best cooks.

“Well then, it’s not about the best home cooks then, is it? Which is what the show is meant to be about.”

But not everyone agreed with the criticism.

Advertisement

“It’s strategic voting, people! Not cheating! Get with the program,” one viewer argued.

Another defended Simon, arguing that you have to do whatever it takes to take home the prize.

“It’s a competition to win $100K. Do whatever you have to do to win.”

And while it seems the majority of viewers were ready to come at Simon with pitchforks, a few pointed out that strategic scoring doesn’t exactly go against the show’s rules.

Advertisement

“In MKR there are no rules saying you can’t low-score a dish. Simon and Angus are there to win money, not friends,” wrote one fan.

How will My Kitchen Rules‘ new scoring twist work?

Well, things are about to get very interesting if the preview for Monday night’s episode is anything to go by.

The promo has revealed that the remaining teams will now have to deliver their critiques directly to the contestants who prepared the food.

Advertisement

Bet Simon’s feeling the heat now!

The change comes as the competition moves into its Ultimate Instant Restaurant round, with Harrison and Oliver hosting the first dinner party.

And given how outspoken Angus and Simon have been about their fellow contestants’ cooking, it’ll be interesting to see whether they’re quite as forthcoming when the people they’re criticising are sitting across from them.

One viewer had already suggested a similar approach to discourage strategic scoring.

“The only way to stop strategic scoring to some degree is for the contestants to reveal their scores in front of all of the teams and the judges at the table,” they wrote.

“It will be interesting to see how it plays out this week as they have to do this.”

Of course, having to explain why you didn’t enjoy someone’s cooking is one thing. Whether it stops contestants from giving deliberately low scores is another.

My Kitchen Rules‘ Krysten and Lucy reveal why their scores came as a shock

If anyone knows what it feels like to be on the receiving end of unexpected scores, it’s eliminated mother-daughter duo Krysten and Lucy.

Lucy and Krysten MKR 2026
My Kitchen Rules fans believe Lucy and Krysten were wronged by their elimination. Credit: Channel Seven.

Speaking exclusively to WHO, Krysten revealed that the feedback received during their cook had left them feeling fairly confident about where they stood in the competition.

“We were, and still are, really happy with that cook. And we didn’t feel like we should have been on the bottom,” she explained.

“They didn’t air a lot of the positive critiques on our dish, and we came away from the critique at the table literally going, ‘Okay, well, we’re not on the top, but we’re definitely not in the bottom.'”

Unfortunately, their final scores told a different story.

“Because we’re the sort of people that if we stuff it up, we will own that 100%,” Krysten said.

“But we honestly didn’t feel like we stuffed anything up.”

Guess we’ll have to tune in to tonight’s episode to see whether the new format will make contestants think twice about strategic scoring.

Related stories


Advertisement
Advertisement