Ready for a whirlwind of drama, scandal, and sisterhood? The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives has officially arrived, and its cast is packed with personalities ready to spill their deepest secrets on screen. From viral TikTok scandals to surprising celebrity connections (yes, that Ben Affleck!), these eight Mormon mums are about to shake up your reality TV lineup.
Let’s dive into the cast, the controversies, and the unexpected twists that make this new series an absolute must-watch.
Taylor Frankie Paul
The Scandal’s Star
If you’ve heard of the infamous 2022 TikTok “soft-swinging” scandal, you’ve probably heard of Taylor Frankie Paul. At just 30, she’s the epicentre of the drama that rocked #MomTok. Taylor’s public split from her husband, Tate, after allegations of extramarital activity blew up social media, and the aftermath is still sending shockwaves. But what makes this even juicier? Taylor introduced her new boyfriend-turned-fiancé, Dakota Mortensen, just a month after the scandal broke, and the two welcomed their first child, Ever, in May 2024.
With two children from her previous marriage (Indy and Ocean), Taylor is ready to share her journey from scandal to redemption. But with her past still looming large, will she ever truly escape the drama?
Jenn Affleck
The Celebrity Connection
Yes, you read that right—Jenn Affleck is related to the Ben Affleck. Jenn, 25, is married to Zac Affleck, Ben’s cousin. While she’s not quite Hollywood royalty, this connection adds an extra layer of intrigue. Jenn and Zac share two kids, and she’s using the show to open up about the trials and tribulations of their marriage.
In the trailer, Jenn teases that the show gave her and Zac “ten years of marriage counselling in one season,” hinting that her personal life may be more complicated than it seems. Could family reunions with Ben be just as spicy?
Mikayla Matthews
The Raw Reality Check
At 24, Mikayla Matthews has already lived through a lifetime of drama, and the scandal wasn’t easy for her to navigate. The former teen mum has 2.4 million TikTok followers and was directly affected by the “swinging” rumours. She’s determined to use the show to offer a fresh perspective on Mormonism and her life outside the spotlight.
In the trailer, Mikayla hints at the emotional fallout she’s faced, revealing how the accusations have impacted her relationships with the other women. Can she rebuild the trust that was lost, or will the tension push her further away from the group?
Whitney Leavitt
The Pregnant Baker and Twerker
Whitney Leavitt, 31, has built a TikTok empire by combining baking and twerking—an unlikely but winning combo! Pregnant with her third child, she’s ready to show a different side of herself, one that dives into her friendships and business ventures with the other women.
Whitney promises that The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives will stand out from other reality shows because the cast’s relationships are real and long-standing. With 2 million followers, she’s sure to keep fans entertained with both her family life and entrepreneurial spirit.
Jessi Ngatikaura
The “Grandma” of the Group
At 32, Jessi Ngatikaura may be the oldest of the group, but that only means she’s got more wisdom—and drama—under her belt. She’s a hairstylist and beauty entrepreneur who runs a successful hair extension company, JZ Styles, while balancing life as a mum of three.
With a divorce and remarriage behind her, Jessi isn’t afraid to tackle tough conversations about faith, family, and relationships. Will her role as the “grandma” of the group mean she’s a source of stability, or is she in for some drama of her own?
Layla Taylor
The Youngest and the Underdog
At just 23, Layla Taylor is the youngest of the group, and she’s got a lot on her plate. A single mother of two, Layla’s TikTok following is modest at 26.7k, but that’s sure to skyrocket once the show starts airing.
Layla’s journey through divorce and single motherhood is expected to take centre stage in The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives. Will the group embrace her as the baby of the bunch, or will the pressures of fame push her out of the spotlight?
Mayci Neeley
From Tennis Star to CEO
Former tennis star turned CEO, Mayci Neeley, 29, swapped her racket for running a natal nutrition company called Babymama. She’s a powerhouse mum of two, who’s candid about her IVF journey and the challenges of blending her family with her husband Jacob Neeley.
With 2 million followers on TikTok, Mayci’s balancing act between family, business, and personal challenges will undoubtedly add some entrepreneurial flair to the drama. Can she keep it all together, or will cracks start to show in her picture-perfect life?
Demi Engemann
Blending Families and Breaking Barriers
Rounding out the cast is 30-year-old Demi Engemann. She’s been through a lot—divorce, remarriage, and blending her family with husband Bret Engemann, 46. With three kids in the mix, Demi is passionate about empowering women through motherhood.
With 304.7k TikTok followers, Demi’s goal is to share her journey while inspiring other mums. But as she dives deeper into her past, will the pressure of airing her personal life bring her closer to the group—or push her further away?
Get Ready for the Drama
The cast of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives is nothing short of captivating. From explosive scandals to surprising celebrity ties, each woman brings her own story, struggles, and secrets to the table. As they navigate faith, friendship, and fame, viewers will be treated to the juiciest drama to come out of Utah.
So, grab the popcorn and get ready—this is reality TV at its finest!
Stream The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives on Disney Plus from $13.99/mth. SUBSCRIBE NOW.