"Could it be Marina Pryor?" asked Matt Dalton, during the Octopus’s performance.
"I was going to say Doris Day, but Doris Day's dead," Anastasia hilariously noted to Faye.
While Octopus' unmasking as Gretel Killeen drew surprise from the families -- they all agreed that Wolf was the best singer, even if they couldn't agree on who was behind the mask.
"Dane Swan, it's DANE SWAN, I'm telling you" Anastasia shouted.
"It doesn't sound anything like Dane Swan!" Faye said, when Wolf began singing Shania Twain's, "Man, I Feel Like A Woman".
To which Anastasia rightly replied: "And what do you know what Dane Swan sounds like!?"
While the Wolf’s identity hasn’t been revealed yet, Last week a radio producer appeared to give the game away, posting a picture of himself and the Wolf to Twitter, captioning the pic: “Me with @RobMillsyMills earlier today. #MaskedSingerAU.”
WATCH: Gogglebox's Anastasia Katselas reveals she's living with her man