While there were many breakout moments at Sunday evening’s Academy Awards, Garner, who introduced Eddie Vedder’s performance, quickly became the subject of the Internet’s latest must-see gif as the actress appeared to have an oh-my-God-epiphany moment during the ceremony.
Garner was applauding with the rest of the audience, including seat neighbor Chris Messina, when her hands noticeably stopped and her facial expression transitioned from stoic to bewildered.
“What realization did Jennifer Garner just come to?” one fan tweeted along with a three-second loop of footage showing the star’s baffled reaction.
And everyone had their theory as to what Garner realized during the Oscars.
Jennifer Garner is me every 5 seconds of life — Sahar Bandbaz (@itsaharrr) March 5, 2018
“Probably realized she left the curling iron on,” a fan captioned their meme.
One user even tweeted a reference to ex Ben Affleck’s career move as caped crusader Batman.
Before the show, Garner was trending when she walked the red carpet in her breathtaking cobalt Versace gown. She also paid homage to the old school beauty looks stars love wearing to the Oscars with her side-swept wavy blowout.
The 90th Oscars were held at the Dolby Theatre at Hollywood & Highland Center on March 4, 2018, and were telecast live on ABC.
This article originally appeared on PEOPLE.