Kardashian West, 37, took on the late singer’s look from her 2001 hit “Try Again,”wearing a bejeweled choker, with a matching bra and black pants. Naturally, she showed off the costume on social media, writing, “Baby Girl Aaliyah.”
Social media users quickly took notice, and began criticizing the star.
“Legend or not Aaliyah is a black woman and you’re not. It’s offensive and you shouldn’t push this limit, but ok…,” one person tweeted to the star.
Another Twitter user simply wrote: “Kim Kardashian as Aaliyah? It’s a no.”
This isn’t the first time the mom of two has faced claims of cultural appropriation and racism. She was accused over the summer of blackface after she posted promotional photos from a shoot to rep her Kim Kardashian West beauty line. She also came under fire just months later for defending makeup artist and beauty vlogger Jeffree Star’s racist comments.
The controversy nearly overshadowed Kardashian West’s other show-stopping Halloween looks — she also dressed as Madonna and Cher. However, some found nothing wrong with the star’s Aaliyah display.
“I HATE when y’all make me defend Kim Kardashian but her Aaliyah costume was nothing even adjacent to cultural appropriation. Please stop,” a social media user tweeted.
“Someone explain to me what’s wrong with Kim Kardashian dressing as Aaliyah…. she looks great,” another added.
One person pointed to Aaliyah’s legendary star status as reason for the backlash, writing, “I think the reason ppl are mad that Kim Kardashian dressed as Aaliyah for Halloween is cause Aaliyah is precious to most!”
The Keeping Up with the Kardashians star wasn’t the only celeb to dress as the “Rock the Boat” singer.
Fifth Harmony’s Normani Kordei nearly broke the internet when she dressed as Aaliyah’s Queen Akasha character from the 2002 movie Queen of the Damned.
This article originally appeared on PEOPLE.