"Is this a producing stunt," co-host Holly Richards asked.
Real Talk co-host Ali Cromarty pointed out that it was just a day before the couple did the deed, they were in the emergency room.
"I was surprised it happened that quickly when the previous night he went to the hospital because he had an anxiety attack and had tummy pains," Ali pointed out.
Given the viewers never saw any footage of Lauren and Matthew getting hot and heavy, there's every possibility that the pair never actually had sex, only said they did.
To hear all about the conspiracy theory that Matthew is still a virgin, listen to the latest episode of Real Talk with Holly & Ali below.