'This game has many twists and turns... Shonee's an amazing girl... I'm really stoked she was able to come back into the game,' the AFL star said.
'Abbey says let bygones be bygones,' the host chimed to Shonee, whose response was impartial.
'We'll have to wait and see,' Shonee told Jonathan with a wry smile. Abbey appeared shook.
Stepping up to write a name down, Shon held up a parchment emblazoned 'Abbey'.
'I hope you're the one being blindsided tonight, not me,' she said to the camera, while Abbey called her rival a contestant with 'nine lives' who she wants gone.
In the end, Shon rallied the 'cool' troops - Locky, Brooke, Flick - and the rest to overpower footy star Abbey.