'Now I can't unsee the hole in his bottom lip from the piercing,' said one person.
Another fan even thought Ryan reminded them of American singer Kevin Jonas in the throwback pic.
In the original post, Ryan wrote: “In youth we learn; in age we understand. Lulu and I 10 years ago.”
During last week’s show, Angie Kent was left furious after learning that Ryan had originally auditioned for Ali Oetjen’s season of the show.
"Apparently he came just for me but apparently he also auditioned for f***ing Ali! So…," Angie said, before adding: “Oh my god, what if he slides into Ali’s DMs too?”
"You know what, I kinda think if it’s meant to be, it will and I’m just going to leave it to the universe," Ryan replied.