On Monday's episode, host Tom Gleisner asked Sophie whether there was a moment she knew it was over with Nick Cummins.
"I think it was as I was walking up to him, he wasn't really looking at me, in my eyes."
Thinking back to the New Caledonia finale, the 25-year-old added, "And yeah I was like, oh, I really would just love to turn around right now but I can't."
The show also forced Brittany to relive the moment Nick dumped her.
The 30-year-old asked the comedians what Nick said to her at that final ceremony.
Ed Kavalee tried to make the Bachie contestant laugh when he told her, "Don't read the card - you were there!"
Proving to be great sports, the girls were in a fit of giggles when the comedy show created a video package showing that the Honey Badger ended up with Sophie Monk's runner-up Jarrod Woodgate.
Nick's exes all seem to be moving on from the rollercoaster TV show.
This week, New Idea revealed exclusive photos of Brittany Hockley and Cassandra Wood having a fabulous girls night with Sophie Tieman. In fact, Cass and Britt even exchanged a steamy kiss.
On Sunday, Sophie sat down with Lisa Wilkinson about her experience.
Summing up what many felt, she said, "I would hope he's a little embarrassed, we just went through so many highs and so many lows."
"And I'm sure he did too – but I just hope there's something in him that's a little unhappy or uneasy with his decision because God knows we have been through it."