On Monday's episode, host Tom Gleisner asked Sophie whether there was a moment she knew it was over with Nick Cummins.
"I think it was as I was walking up to him, he wasn't really looking at me, in my eyes."
Thinking back to the New Caledonia finale, the 25-year-old added, "And yeah I was like, oh, I really would just love to turn around right now but I can't."
The show also forced Brittany to relive the moment Nick dumped her.
The 30-year-old asked the comedians what Nick said to her at that final ceremony.
Ed Kavalee tried to make the Bachie contestant laugh when he told her, "Don't read the card - you were there!"
Proving to be great sports, the girls were in a fit of giggles when the comedy show created a video package showing that the Honey Badger ended up with Sophie Monk's runner-up Jarrod Woodgate.
Nick's exes all seem to be moving on from the rollercoaster TV show.
On Sunday, Sophie sat down with Lisa Wilkinson about her experience.
Summing up what many felt, she said, "I would hope he's a little embarrassed, we just went through so many highs and so many lows."
"And I'm sure he did too – but I just hope there's something in him that's a little unhappy or uneasy with his decision because God knows we have been through it."