Chatting with bartenders at N.Y.C. hotspot Dexler's, Brinkley is asked her "favorite" pick up line.
"Will you marry me?" she says with a laugh. "I fell for it four times."
Brinkley has been married four times – to Francois Allaux (1973–81), Billy Joel (1985–94), Richard Taubman (1994–95) and Peter Cook (1996–2008).
Brinkley, 62, has three children from the relationships: Alexa Ray Joel, 30, and Jack and Sailor Cook, 21 and 18 respectively.