Advertisement
Home Entertainment Reality Tv

My Kitchen Rules: Channel 7 responds to Jane’s claims she was ‘forced’ to cook disastrous pigeon dish

The controversial contestant claims she was pressured into cooking the dish that made her a target for online trolls.
Jane MKR 2026
Former MKR contestant Jane has made some explosive claims about the controversial pigeon dish she and Shane cooked on the show. Credit: Channel 7.
Advertisement

Who knew reality TV wasn’t always what it seemed? At least, that’s what former My Kitchen Rules contestant Jane is suggesting after making some pretty explosive claims about her time on the show.

The food stylist took to Instagram to allege that she and her teammate Shane were “forced and coerced” into cooking the now-infamous pigeon dish that made her a target for online trolls.

While Jane was already a controversial contestant, her latest claims may have viewers either side-eyeing her even more or feeling some empathy for what she’s gone through.

And her allegations have sparked fresh speculation about what really happens in the kitchen and how much control contestants have over their choices.

Advertisement
Loading the player…

What has My Kitchen Rules‘ Jane said about the pigeon dish?

The bombshell revelation sat alongside a photo of a pigeon dish from Grandfather’s restaurant in Sydney’s CBD – it was that same plate of food that served as inspiration for the meal she and Shane whipped up on the show.

“This dish became the ‘foundation’ for a dish we were recently forced and coerced into cooking,” she wrote.

“A dish that saw us the laughing stock of the country and gave some pretty awful people fodder to bully me about my appearance, my style, my attitude. Thousands and thousands of people.”

Advertisement

She continued, alleging that before filming kicked off, both Jane and Shane told producers that they didn’t feel confident in preparing the dish. However, their concerns seemed to have fallen on deaf ears.

“A dish that we repeatedly reinforced that we had NEVER cooked successfully and that we did not want to cook.”

Regardless, she urged her followers to visit Grandfather’s restaurant and try the dish out themselves, before ending her caption with a pretty direct message.

Advertisement

“This one was excellent. Get to grandfathers to try this incredibly beautiful dish, and don’t bother trying to replicate it yourself – it’s a very hard protein to cook!”

“Also, don’t believe everything you watch on TV.”

My Kitchen Rules viewers are divided over Jane’s claims

Like most things posted on the internet, Jane’s Instagram post has found its way over to Reddit, where viewers are questioning just how much influence producers had when it came to the controversial dish.

“From what I heard contestants submit a range of recipes and they are then told what to cook by production,” one Reddit user claimed.

Advertisement

The same commenter alleged that parts of the show, such as the restaurant themes, decorations and the edit the contestants receive, are heavily influenced by production.

Another said it was for this same reason that they stopped watching the show.

“It’s heavily manipulated and producers are looking for ways to deliberately create drama and conflict. It’s no longer about food or cooking ability,” they wrote.

“If some contestants are given options they are likely to fail at then it’s not really a fair competition.”

Advertisement
Jane and Shane's Instant Restaurant ended up being a disaster as their pigeons were overcooked. Credit: Channel Seven.
Jane and Shane’s Instant Restaurant ended up being a disaster as their pigeons were overcooked. Credit: Channel Seven.

However, not everyone was on Jane’s side, with some saying the dish was no excuse for the way she acted on screen.

“My understanding was that the contestants submit their initial ideas, so wouldn’t the desiccated pigeon corpse have been their idea initially?” one person questioned.

“Why submit it as an idea if you’re not confident cooking it?”

During Jane’s time on the show, online trolls took aim at her appearance, which Redditors acknowledged was wrong, but they also argued that contestants were responsible for their own behaviour.

“I agree that appearance shaming is wrong, but with respect to the food and the attitude, that’s on the competitor,” one wrote.

“I get the whole villain edit is a thing, but you’ve still gotta say that stuff for them to film it.”

Others were even less sympathetic.

“Whether or not that’s true doesn’t alter how nasty she was towards every other contestant; no one made her behave like that,” another commented.

Has Channel Seven responded to Jane’s allegations?

Jane’s Instagram post has shed light on what allegedly goes on behind the scenes, and just how much control contestants have over the food they make in the kitchen. However, her claims are yet to be independently verified.

WHO contacted Channel Seven regarding Jane’s allegations. While the network declined to provide an official comment, it did explain how the process works.

According to the network, contestants submit a collection of their favourite recipes, from which producers select menu items to ensure variety and avoid repetition at the instant restaurants.

Well, there you have it, folks.

Related stories


Advertisement
Advertisement