The internet may be obsessed with the likes of Drew Starkey and Harris Dickinson in 2025, but in 2012, Tumblr could not get enough of The Amazing Spider-Man star Andrew Garfield.
Despite the fan fervour surrounding the 41-year-old British star taking a bit of a backseat on social media in recent years, many fans (us included) still hold a firm place in our hearts for the internet’s original hot boy of the month.
Following his split from co-star Emma Stone in 2015 after four years together, Andrew enthusiasts have been keeping a close eye on the actor’s love life to see if the star has found his new romance.
Who is Andrew Garfield dating?
Andrew Garfield is rumoured to be in a relationship with A Complete Unknown star Monica Barbaro.
While the two actors have not commented on the speculation, Andrew and Movia were first spotted sitting side-by-side supporting Jonathan Bailey during a performance of Richard II in London’s West End, leading many fans to believe that the pair could be an item.
“They’ve been really lowkey and have been spending time together quietly,” a source told People.
Just over a week after rumours of their relationship surfaced, the pair were once again spotted together leaving the Vanity Fair Oscars After Party before later arriving at Beyonce and Jay Z’s post-Academy Awards event, with photos shared by the Daily Mail showing Andrew and Erica walking together outside of the venue.
Although they’ve yet to hit the red carpet together, Andrew and Monica were spotted after the actress’s debut at the 2025 Met Gala, with a video shared by Cosmopolitan showing the couple reuniting in the lobby of The Mark Hotel in New York ahead of the official afterparty.
News of Andrew’s rumoured new romance comes just over six months after his former girlfriend, Dr Kate Tomas confirmed that the couple had parted ways.
Revealing the news as part of an Instagram Q&A, Kate responded to a fan who asked, “Are you still dating Andrew Garfield? If so, tell him I’m a fan of him, please,” with the details, writing, “We broke up months ago but I’m sure he will be happy to know that he is loved.”
While he did not address their split directly, Andrew told Esquire, “I have never, and I won’t ever, speak about or confirm or deny anything about my personal life with anyone, ever.”
Who has Andrew Garfield dated?
Olivia Brower
(January 2024)
Before his most recent relationship rumours, Andrew was reported to be in a relationship with 28-year-old Sports Illustrated model Olivia Brower.
In early January 2024, pictures obtained by The Sun offered fans the first glimpse of the rumoured new couple, with the snaps showing Andrew and Olivia kissing outside his home in London after he helped her place her luggage in the back of a taxi.
Alyssa Miller
(2021-2022)
In late 2021, Andrew was previously linked to Sports Illustrated model, 35-year-old Alyssa Miller.
The pair are said to have first crossed paths in November 2021 and were last spotted together at the 2022 SAG Awards. The couple reportedly called it quits not long after, with a source telling The Sun that the pair split as a result of their conflicting schedules.
“Andrew and Alyssa were a really beautiful couple and things were going great at first. They were together for quite some time before they went public, but work schedules mean it has been really hard to see each other,” a source previously told the publication.
“On top of that, it became clear that there were some differences between them and it was decided they are better off apart, for now at least.”
Want to discover your love story? Start your journey today for FREE with eHarmony.
