Trigger Warning: Sexual Assault, Violence, Gun Violence.
The three-part Netflix docu-series, Reality Check: Inside America’s Next Top Model, revisits the chaos of the Tyra Banks-created show, but through a far more critical lens. What once passed as edgy reality television now raises serious questions about power, exploitation, and duty of care.
At its peak, ANTM defined early-2000s reality television. It launched careers, created cultural catchphrases, and built a global franchise. However, the legacy of it is complicated- the glamour was real, but so was the damage.
Here are the most shocking revelations from the docu-series:
Shandi’s scandal
Creative director Jay Alexander, AKA. Miss Jay, admits many contestants came from unstable home environments and were looking for validation from the show. That context casts a long shadow over what happened to Shandi Sullivan in Cycle 2.
Shandi left home at 18 with nothing more than a supportive boyfriend behind her who encouraged her to sign up for the show. However, while filming in Milan, producers invited male models into the contestants’ apartment and encouraged heavy drinking.
In the flashback we see a highly-intoxicated Shandi “cheating” on her boyfriend, “I was blackout and nobody did anything to stop it,” she recalls in the docu-series.
Executive producer Ken Mok defended filming the incident, saying contestants were told they would be recorded 24/7 with no interference. But seriously, how does he sleep at night after airing that!
The fallout was devastating. Shandi had to call her boyfriend on camera- both sobbing, screaming, heartbroken. Crew members reportedly told her afterward, “We’re really, really sorry we had to film that.” The scene remains one of reality TV’s most uncomfortable moments.
The one shoot producers are sorry for
If Reality Check proves anything, it’s that some of ANTM’s most controversial creative choices haunt even its producers.
In Cycle 8, models were made to pose as different crime scene victims- styled as though they had been violently murdered, and for model Dionne Walters, the crime victim shoot was particularly personal.
Dionne was told to pose as if someone had “shot her in the head” despite producers knowing her own mother was left paralysed after being shot herself.
Recalling the horrible shoot in the docu-series, Dionne said: “They knew about it from the application process, but they still chose to have me do this particular photo shoot that involved gun violence. I thought it was a coincidence at the time, but I don’t think it was.”
During the episode, a photographer complained on camera that contestant Dionne didn’t “take initiative” or improvise enough.
Looking back, Dionne offers a very different interpretation: “I don’t think they wanted to see some type of mental breakdown, or to see me crumble. I’m just glad that they didn’t get the reaction that I feel like they were hoping to get.”
Even ANTM’s executive producers Ken Mok now expresses regret. In Reality Check, he says: “I take full responsibility for that shoot. That was a mistake. I look back now and I think it was a celebration of violence. It was crazy. That one I look back on and I’m like, ‘You were an idiot.'”
Humiliation ritual
Former winner Danielle Evans recalls being forced to pose with raw fish draped across her body. At the time, it was framed as avant-garde fashion.
She now sees it differently: “This is not real modelling. It’s public humiliation.”
Other contestants recount being pressured into bikini and even intimate waxing on camera- presented as “model prep,” but experienced as invasive and degrading.
Joanie’s dental nightmare
Joanie Dodds underwent one of the most extreme makeovers in the show’s history as dentist Danny Vranjes removed four of her teeth in a single marathon session that reportedly stretched through the night.
While the episode framed it as a triumphant transformation, Joanie now says she has a severe bite issue that will never be fully corrected. What aired as inspirational television left lasting physical consequences.
Keenyah’s on-set harassment
During a music video shoot, Keenyah Hill says a male model repeatedly groped her. She tried to halt production but felt ignored. “Being on set with 50 people and not feeling protected is very dark,” she admitted.
Rcealling the patronising pep talk she gave Keenyah, Tyra said: “I felt like that was empowering her based on the information that I had.”
The infamous meltdown
The “WE WERE ALL ROOTING FOR YOU!” moment has become one of the most viral ANTM moments in history. But according to photographer Nigel Barker, the model’s meltdown at Tiffany Richardson was far more intense than viewers saw.
“Tyra really scared all of us,” he says. Creative director Jay Manuel claims much more was said that never aired- serious enough that legal teams were involved the following week.
Host and executive producer Tyra Banks later reflected: “I went too far. I lost it. It was bigger than her- it was me sticking up for black women who felt like they didn’t deserve to be here.”
Jay Manuel’s mental torture
Behind the scenes, cracks were forming. Jay Manuel says he emailed Tyra to tell her he planned to quit. After three days without a response, she replied only: “I am disappointed.”
Soon after, he received a letter from attorneys that effectively forced him back to work. He describes returning to set as “psychological torture,” claiming Tyra would only speak to him when cameras were rolling.
Tyra declined detailed comment in the docu-series but with soulless eyes said: “I should call Jay. He’s a special man.”
The Page Six “leak”
When long-standing panel members were let go, the news “leaked” to Page Six before a planned group announcement. Nigel Barker was reportedly devastated.
Jay questioned why those who had been there since the show’s inception weren’t allowed to “move forward with grace.”
Tyra maintains it wasn’t her decision and says she “cried herself to sleep,” adding that producers told her there were “no sacred cows.”
Miss Jay’s Stroke
In December 2022, Jay Alexander suffered a stroke and spent five weeks in a coma. Jay Manuel and Nigel Barker visited him, and they revealed how they all cried together and reminisced on their good times.
Tyra did not visit in person, but according to Miss Jay, she sent a text saying she would.
Never one to lose his sense of humour, he looked into the camera and lowered his glasses and gave the classic look that says “we’ll see” without saying anything at all.
Related stories
Native ad body.
Native ad body.
Native ad body.
