Meet Katie and Tim, one of the most talked-about couples on this season of Married at First Sight.
Katie, a 37-year-old CEO from Queensland, and Tim, a 38-year-old primary school teacher from Victoria, seemed like they could be the perfect match on paper. Katie, who has spent the last decade single, was looking for a family man to settle down with, while Tim was eager to find someone genuine after heartbreak halted his plans to propose years ago.
But despite their shared hopes, their wedding day journey revealed that first impressions aren’t always what they seem, and after Tim seemingly vanished after the wedding, fans were dying to know whether their disastrous nuptials marked the end of their romance.

What happened at Katie and Tim’s wedding?
Katie’s wedding day began with tears of excitement—and fear. As she tried on wedding dresses with her bridesmaids, the idea of marrying a stranger left her feeling vulnerable but optimistic. Meanwhile, Tim stood at the altar, exuding warmth and kindness, qualities that immediately reassured Katie’s family.
When Katie walked down the aisle and met Tim for the first time, her smile said it all—she was happy. Tim, however, was harder to read. While their vows aligned perfectly, hinting at similar values and goals, the cracks started to show almost immediately.
Their first kiss as husband and wife was telling. Tim wiped it away, an action that didn’t go unnoticed by viewers—and certainly not by Katie. When asked by producers how he felt about his new bride, Tim admitted he wasn’t sure. “I just haven’t got that initial spark,” he confessed.
Tim further revealed that Katie wasn’t what he usually went for, preferring “short, petite blondes or brunettes.” Despite acknowledging her beauty, he struggled with their lack of physical chemistry, describing himself as “deflated” and “embarrassed.”
Katie’s optimism carried her through the awkward photoshoot, where she tried to connect with Tim despite his reserved demeanour. However, the reception proved even more challenging. While Katie mingled with loved ones and remained hopeful, Tim kept his distance. His best man encouraged him to keep an open mind, but Tim admitted he didn’t feel the connection he was hoping for.
By the end of the night, Katie’s concerns bubbled to the surface. She pulled Tim aside, worried that his behaviour signalled he wasn’t attracted to her. Tim reassured her, apologizing for his awkwardness and explaining that the day had been overwhelming. He told her she was genuine and had put him at ease, leaving Katie convinced that her earlier doubts were a misunderstanding.

Are Katie and Tim still together?
But Katie’s relief was short-lived. Later that night, Tim finally admitted he wasn’t feeling a spark. Devastated, Katie confided in producers that rejection was her worst fear and that this was her “worst nightmare” come true. “I don’t know what I did wrong,” she said through tears.
The mood between the couple was sombre the next day. Katie admitted she felt humiliated, describing the spark conversation as a “cop-out.” Tim, though still open to giving their relationship a chance, asked Katie if she wanted to go on the honeymoon.
For Katie, the experience has been an emotional rollercoaster, from feeling hopeful and optimistic to questioning whether their relationship even has a future. Tim, meanwhile, remains unsure, admitting that honesty with Katie is difficult and that he doesn’t see the spark growing—at least not yet.
With a rocky start and trust already hanging by a thread, the couple headed into their honeymoon with uncertainty and things have gone from bad to worse throughout the first week.

Following a tense first dinner party, Katie’s move-in experience was less of a fresh start and more of a solo mission. Arriving at the apartments alone, she was feeling understandably defeated. “There’s just been a lot of rejection, a lot of not wanting to be with me,” she admitted, holding back tears. But despite the heartbreak, she remained determined. “I am committed. I want to understand why the experts matched us together.”
The problem? Tim was nowhere to be found. He hadn’t turned up at the apartments, and the last time they’d seen each other was at the dinner party. Producers informed Katie that he had gone back to Melbourne to “collect his thoughts.” Her response? “What a selfish p***k.”
Thankfully, Katie wasn’t entirely alone. Fellow brides Ashleigh and Jamie rallied around her, offering support as she processed Tim’s disappearing act. But with one-half of the couple already halfway out the door, it’s looking like Katie’s MAFS journey might be a one-woman show.

With the future of their relationship up in the air, Tim returned to the show alongside Katie for their first commitment ceremony of the season.
Sitting in front of the experts, their lack of connection was immediately evident to the experts. Justifying his sudden exit, Tim told the panel, “When you feel that someone’s not there for you, that’s not a partner I want,” before adding that despite her shock at his departure, Katie had not made any attempt to contact him.
While he may have tried to place the blame for their failed romance on Katie, expert John Aiken was quick to set the record straight.
“You deflected, you blamed her for everything, you said she broke your trust, you said that you were the most honest of the two of you and ultimately made her feel like she was going crazy,” he shared.
With tensions high, the time finally came for Tim and Katie to decide whether they wanted to give their romance a second chance and, to the shock of literally nobody, the couple both voted to leave the show.
As they left their latest chance at love behind, Katie later opened up on the days leading up to the commitment ceremony, telling Nine, “I knew something was wrong at the wedding. I could see him in the distance wigging out.”
“I told him it would be in his best interest to take it day by day and just get to the commitment ceremony, and if we need to leave, then we could leave as friends, but instead he decided to create a war path,” said Katie.
“You don’t have to like me, you don’t have to love me, you don’t even have to be attracted to me in the slightest amount but just communicate that and we can part ways as friends.”
Want a love story of your own without the drama? Start your love journey for FREE today, with eHarmony.