Whether or not the affair took place behind the scenes has been a huge point of contention. As we know, Mikey maintains he "had sex" with Stacey after he parted ways with his television wife, Natasha Spencer, saying: “I can confirm we did have sex, but it was clearly after Natasha and I had agreed with producers that our relationship was over, and Natasha knew we weren’t together."
"Mikey looks like my son, there's no way," Stacey said in February. "He is not my type. What happened was I was in Adelaide when he hooked up with Hayley and no one told me what was going on and I was all alone."
She echoed a similar sentiment in a recent interview with New Idea, declaring: "Nothing happened between Mikey Pembroke and I. No sexual relations. Nothing. I can guarantee that. And I can sit here and swear on anything. I understand where the rumours came from but I swear that Mikey and I have never shared any sexual intimacy."
In spite of this, many of their co-stars have sided with Mikey, including Hayley Vernon who believes Stacey is in too deep to come forward and reveal the truth.
"Yeah, it's Mikey," Hayley said when KIIS FM's Jackie 'O' Henderson asked who Stacey was hooking up with behind Michael's back.
"Stacey and someone else are pretty much trying to bring Mikey down at the moment and say that, you know, he's a terrible person, that he's got a bad character, that he's making all this stuff up to stay in the spotlight and to totally defame Stacey," she continued.
"It's utter bullsh*t. Stacey just can't stand on her own two feet and cop it on the chin and I'm pretty sure that Mikey's going to do a lie detector test to prove that he did get a leg over Stacey," the bodybuilder continued, hinting the truth will be exposed at the upcoming reunion episode.