“Who doesn’t love the Golden Globes?” asks Binge List host Matthew Denby. “It’s the most fun of the awards shows,” agrees co-host Gavin Scott. “The Hollywood Foreign Press Association [HFPA] assemble the top TV and movie stars in one room and ply them with alcohol.” The Globes also “shine a light on emerging shows and talent,” adds co-host Clare Rigden. WHO’s TV critics look at this year’s TV nominations – head to goldenglobes.com for the full list – and reveal which shows and actors they think deserve to win.
BEST DRAMA
Clare Ridgen Given it’s the HFPA voting, there’s every chance BBC America’s Killing Eve, with its decidedly international cast, will win. That and the fact star Sandra Oh is this year’s Globes host – convenient! If not, it may go to Homecoming, starring the very excellent Julia Roberts.
Gavin Scott It’s up against strong contenders Homecoming, Bodyguard (which was one of 2018’s most buzzworthy shows, but it fizzled out for me) and the excellent final season of The Americans, but the inventiveness of Killing Eve should triumph. I don’t think Pose is in with a chance – Ryan Murphy will win elsewhere.
Matthew Denby I nominated Killing Eve as my favourite show of 2018 on Binge List – and it deserves to win. Oh is great in this espionage thriller as she tracks her murderous quarry across Europe, and the writing is so crisp and original. This excellent effort really is the product of great teamwork.
Loading the player...
BEST MUSICAL OR COMEDY
CR The Marvelous Mrs Maisel scooped the pool at the Emmys and last year’s Globes, but something tells me the HFPA has moved on. The Kominsky Method may nudge it out of the running. You can’t underestimate the popularity of stars Michael Douglas and Alan Arkin with the HFPA old guard. My money’s on Kominsky, but my heart lies with Midge.
GS The HFPA’s picks in this category are often surprising. I would predict a win for underdog The Good Place but Season 3 has been uneven, so while Kominsky is the safe bet, perhaps the superior (in my mind) Barry will defy expectations.
MD Kominsky proves Chuck Lorre isn’t just a cheesy sitcom hack. This excellent comedy also has a lot of emotional depth as it faces decidedly unfunny subjects like death, loneliness and addiction. At its core, The Kominsky Method is about friendship. Douglas and Arkin put a lot of heart into their fraught but caring relationship.
Loading the player...
BEST MINISERIES OR TELEVISION FILM
CR This will be hotly contested, but Sharp Objects is a real contender. Everything about this series from director Jean-Marc Vallée is excellent – the casting (Amy Adams, Patricia Clarkson and Australia’s Eliza Scanlen as the world’s creepiest teen), the writing, the performances, the cinematography – exquisite.
GS Prolific showrunner Ryan Murphy usually does well at the Globes, and so it’s a given The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story will win, right? Escape at Dannemora was the only nominee that had me coming back for more, but I’d be surprised if it wins.
MD Versace is just what many voters love: commercial, emotional and a prime example of celebrity navel gazing. It walks a fine line between tacky exploitative rubbish and depth, and that’s the Globes to a T. The tragic killing of the iconic fashion designer is rendered in lurid style, while serving up deeper commentary about the nature of fame.
For the team’s picks in the acting categories, pick up this week’s issue of WHO magazine. And take a listen to the best of 2018 episode of Binge List below.